Carduus nutans (Nodding Thistle)

Plant Info
Also known as: Nodding Plumeless Thistle, Musk Thistle
Genus:Carduus
Family:Asteraceae (Aster)
Life cycle:biennial
Origin:Europe
Status:
  • Invasive - ERADICATE!
  • Noxious Weed
  • Prohibited or Restricted species
Habitat:sun; fields, along roads
Bloom season:June - October
Plant height:2 to 7 feet
Wetland Indicator Status:GP: FACU MW: FACU NCNE: FACU
MN county distribution (click map to enlarge):Minnesota county distribution map
National distribution (click map to enlarge):National distribution map

Pick an image for a larger view. See the glossary for icon descriptions.

Detailed Information

Flower: Flower shape: indistinct Cluster type: round

[photo of flower] Flower heads are 2 to 3 inches across, purple to pinkish and often nod down, hence the common name. The showy bracts are rather large and generally triangular, in many layers spreading out away from the flower head, and are green or tinged purple. Flowers are single at the end of branching stems.

Leaves and stem: Leaf attachment: alternate Leaf type: lobed Leaf type: simple

[photo of leaves]  Leaves are up to 15 inches long at the base of the plant and deeply lobed, the lobes on lower leaves further divided into several smaller lobes, and becoming smaller and less deeply lobed as they ascend the stem. There are numerous spines along the wavy edges. Leaves are stalkless, mostly hairless except for the main veins on the underside, and may have a white cast on the edges, especially early growth rosettes.

[photo of stem] Leaf bases extend down the stem, forming spiny “wings”. Stems are many branched.

Notes:

Goldfinches are quite fond of Nodding Thistle (and all other thistles) for both the seed and the silks from the seed heads, which they use to line their nests. The large flower heads and broad, showy bracts make this species stand out from the rest, though closely related is Plumeless Thistle (Carduus acanthoides), whose flower heads are rather smaller, with narrow bracts. Nodding Thistle is on the noxious weed list for Minnesota, a common pasture/roadside pest. While not as obnoxious or as widespread as Plumeless Thistle, this species can invade high grade native habitats and is no doubt under-reported in the state. Of note is the MN Weed Advisory Group is recommending this species, currently a Prohibited-Control species, be removed from the noxious weed list because they have determined "infestations [are] primarily caused by human disturbance". The decision seems illogical, since that doesn't make it any less of a pest.

Please visit our sponsors

  • Wild Ones Twin Cities Chapter

Where to buy native seed and plants ↓

Map of native plant purveyors in the upper midwest

  • Natural Shore Technologies - Using science to improve land and water
  • Itasca Ladyslipper Farm - Native orchids, container grown
  • Prairie Restorations - Bringing people together with the land
  • Landscape Alternatives - Distinctive Native Plants since 1986!
  • Shop for native seeds and plants at PrairieMoon.com!

More photos

Photos by K. Chayka taken at Long Lake Regional Park, Ramsey County. Photos courtesy Peter M. Dziuk taken at various locations around the Metro.

Comments

Have you seen this plant in Minnesota, or have any other comments about it?

Posted by: Jane - Hennepin
on: 2011-05-28 14:00:57

Why are these and some of the other thistles on the restricted list? Is there an actual scientific justification for each species somewhere? I hope it's not something stupid like "they are prickly", especially if birds like them.

Posted by: K. Chayka
on: 2011-05-28 19:47:45

The non-native thistles are highly invasive and degrade native habitat. Regardless, many plants are on the noxious weed list because they are an agricultural pest plant that are problematic in grazing and crop fields. As for the birds, there are native thistles that they like just as well. What do you suppose they fed on before the weeds arrived?

Posted by: Rose - Cottonwood
on: 2015-05-20 16:53:30

Unfortunately, these nasty plants are found in Cottonwood County, though they were non-existent 15-20 years ago. The flowers are beautiful, no doubt, but the plants can really spread and take over. We have had most success in controlling them by removing all the blossoms and any buds showing any color and then chopping the plants off at the base. The plant has to be cut up in several smaller pieces because the stems hold a lot of water; any buds on the plant can still blossom and go to seed if the stems are left whole. The best treatment of the flower heads and buds is to dry them out and then burn them.

Posted by: J Ayers - Blue Earth
on: 2018-01-11 18:55:10

Lots of nectar and pollen. Lots of seeds and down for finches. Larval host for Painted Lady. I can think of a lot worse. There are big native North American thistles but people are hardly planting those or growing the seed so it can be planted. So, the answer to the question about what goldfinches were eating — it wasn't strip malls, soybeans, or bags of seed with no thistles.

Posted by: Robert Seper - Plymouth
on: 2018-07-06 21:42:56

Road construction summer 2017 which included our property required fill to be brought in and graded. This year we have been 'blessed' with Nodding Thistle and Bull Thistle. According to the map there was none indicated for Hennepin County. Time to update the map. I sympathize with those who are concerned about birds. Our finch population has dropped off precipitously. So what to do is the question. One thing is for certain, the Bull Thistle will be history.

Posted by: Anita J Hall - Eden Prairie
on: 2019-07-06 21:26:27

There are a dozen or so plants on the west side of Homeward Hills Road just north of Pax Christi church. They are in bloom (6 July) and I stopped to look at them as the blooms are very pretty.

Post a comment

Note: All comments are moderated before posting to keep the riff-raff out. An email address is required, but will not be posted—it will only be used for information exchange between the 2 of us (if needed) and will never be given to a 3rd party without your express permission.

For info on subjects other than plant identification (gardening, invasive species control, edible plants, etc.), please check the links and invasive species pages for additional resources.



(required)




Note: Comments or information about plants outside of Minnesota and neighboring states may not be posted because Id like to keep the focus of this web site centered on Minnesota. Thanks for your understanding.